Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches: A Sweet and Whimsical Christmas Snack for Kids

a nutella sandwich decorated with mms and pretzels to look like a reindeer

Christmas snacks are as much a tradition as ornaments on the tree. Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches are a bite-sized snack that are packed with holiday fun. Picture a tray of tiny reindeer faces, each one made from heart-shaped Nutella sandwiches with pretzel antlers and candy noses. They’re super-cute and full of charm; the kind of treat that ensures Santa will be paying a visit to the house this year. These little reindeer sandwiches combine simple ingredients with big personality. They’re a perfect Christmas snack for kids, or classrooms, and look as good as they taste.

A Christmas Snack for Kids That’s Equal Parts Fun and Delicious

nutella sandwiches cut and decorated with mms and pretzels to look like a reindeer

Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches start with the simplest ingredients: two slices of bread spread generously with Nutella. That classic flavor makes the perfect filling for these sweet sandwiches. Once assembled, the sandwiches are cut into heart shapes. A heart shape is easy to cut out, and makes the perfect base for a reindeer. Mini pretzels make perfect antlers, while candy-coated chocolates serve as bright noses and twinkling eyes. Whether made for a Christmas classroom party snack, a holiday movie night, or an afternoon kitchen project, these sandwiches are guaranteed to bring smiles.

How to Make Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches

Supplies and Ingredients:

Sliced bread (white or wheat)
Nutella spread
Mini pretzels
M&M’s or similar chocolate candies (brown and red)
Heart-shaped cookie cutter or small knife

Instructions:

1. Prepare the sandwiches – Spread a thick, even layer of Nutella on one slice of bread. Place a second slice on top to create a normal sandwich.

2. Cut the shape – Use a heart-shaped cookie cutter to press through the sandwich. If a cutter isn’t available, carefully cut a heart shape using a knife.

sandwiches with pretzels on top to look like deer antlers

3. Add the antlers – Gently press pretzels right on to the bread, in the top corners of the heart. Use a little Nutella so they stick.

4. Create the reindeer face – Use two M&M’s for eyes and one bright red one for the nose. A small dab of Nutella works perfectly as “glue” to hold the candies in place.

5. Let the details set – Allow the sandwiches to rest for a few minutes so the Nutella can firm up slightly and hold everything together.

The end result is an irresistibly cute Christmas treat idea that looks like it came straight from the North Pole bakery.

Ideas for Serving Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches

Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches make wonderful additions to a variety of settings. They can be arranged on a platter for a Christmas classroom party snack, served alongside mugs of hot cocoa during a family night, or tucked into a lunchbox as a sweet surprise. Paired with fruit slices or a handful of popcorn, they become a balanced snack that blends fun and flavor.

These reindeer sandwiches also photograph beautifully, making them an ideal addition to a holiday-themed dessert table. Their playful look can even inspire a themed gathering where kids choose from a plethora of reindeer snacks.

Why Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches Are Perfect for the Season

These Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches feature lots of great flavor, and the process of making them is fun, too. The combination of textures, from the smooth Nutella to the crunchy pretzels and candy-coated chocolate creates a satisfying bite. Each component adds both flavor and personality, allowing every reindeer to offer a variety of sensations.

This Christmas activity for kids encourages creativity in the kitchen and makes snack time feel like a craft session. For those who enjoy making memories through hands-on food projects, this recipe blends culinary fun with a dash of imagination.

Creative Variations to Try

For an extra touch of holiday magic, there are endless ways to customize Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches:

Add a dusting of powdered sugar for a “snowy” look.
Use peanut butter or cookie butter instead of Nutella for a twist in flavor.
Try whole-grain bread for a hearty texture that balances the sweetness.
Add banana slices inside for a creamy, fruity layer that complements the chocolate-hazelnut spread.
Make mini versions using small cookie cutters and broken pretzels for bite-sized party snacks.

These options keep this Christmas treat idea fresh each time the recipe is made, encouraging experimentation with new combinations and decorations.

Tips for Picture-Perfect Reindeer Sandwiches

To achieve the best results, start with soft, fresh bread. It cuts cleanly and holds the shape well. When spreading Nutella, keep the layer thick enough for flavor but not so thick that it squeezes out the sides. If the kitchen is warm, chilling the sandwiches briefly in the refrigerator before decorating can help them stay firm.

For even more detail, outline the reindeer’s nose and eyes with a touch of melted chocolate. Presentation matters, too. Placing the sandwiches on a plate lined with parchment paper or arranging them in rows on a wooden tray instantly makes them look extra special.

A Fun Christmas Activity for Kids

At the heart of this Christmas treat idea is the joy of turning everyday ingredients into something extraordinary. Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches show how a simple Christmas snack for kids can turn into a moment of laughter, creativity, and sweetness. Each sandwich is a small work of art, blending flavor and imagination in every bite.

When the kitchen fills with delighted kids, ready to dig into their reindeer sandwiches, it’s easy to see why these treats capture so much attention. They bring warmth and whimsy to the season, one heart-shaped bite at a time.

Liked These? You May Also Like…

20+ of the best Christmas Ornament Crafts for Kids
Discover 20+ easy Christmas ornament crafts for kids using simple, budget-friendly supplies. This holiday craft roundup includes DIY ornaments perfect for preschool, kindergarten, classroom activities, and family Christmas crafting. Find step-by-step ideas for handmade keepsake ornaments kids will love to make.
Reindeer Ornament Craft: A Sweet and Simple Christmas Keepsake
Easy Christmas Reindeer Popsicle Stick Ornament kids can craft in minutes. Great for holiday decorating, classroom activities, and handmade Christmas ornaments. Find simple instructions for making a popsicle stick reindeer.
Manger Popsicle Stick Craft: A Simple and Meaningful Christmas Keepsake
Easy Manger Popsicle Stick Craft for kids. This simple DIY Christmas nativity craft uses inexpensive supplies and is perfect for homeschool, Sunday school, or classroom Christmas activities. Learn how to make a popsicle stick manger and create a meaningful holiday keepsake with step-by-step instructions.
Christmas Tree Popsicle Stick Ornament: A Festive DIY for Kids
Easy Christmas Tree Popsicle Stick Ornament craft for kids. This simple DIY Christmas craft uses basic supplies and makes a fun holiday activity for home or classroom. Get step-by-step instructions and ideas to decorate your popsicle stick Christmas tree.
Snowman Sensory Bin: A Simple and Engaging Winter Activity for Kids
Create a fun snowman sensory bin for kids using simple winter-themed materials and easy setup instructions. This hands-on activity encourages fine motor skills, imaginative play, and seasonal learning at home or in the classroom. Save this snowman sensory bin idea for your next winter activity with kids.
Christmas Village Houses: Edible Winter Magic in Miniature houses
Build magical edible Christmas village houses with your kids using simple ingredients and step-by-step instructions. This festive holiday activity combines crafting and baking for a creative, delicious winter project. Save this Christmas village idea for family fun all season long.
Oreo Ornament Cookies: A Festive No-Bake Treat for the Holidays
Make these easy Oreo ornament cookies for a fun Christmas treat kids will love. This simple no-bake recipe turns classic Oreos into festive holiday ornaments using just a few ingredients. Perfect for classroom parties, family baking, and adding to Christmas dessert trays. Save this kid-friendly holiday cookie idea for your next Christmas activity.
Yarn Ornament: A Simple and Cozy Christmas Craft for Kids
Make this simple yarn ornament craft for kids using easy supplies and step-by-step instructions. This holiday activity is perfect for classrooms, home projects, and decorating the Christmas tree with handmade ornaments. Save this yarn craft tutorial for your next winter activity with kids.
Moving Polar Bear Craft: A Winter Wonderland in Motion
Try this simple moving polar bear paper plate craft that kids can create with just a few basic supplies. This winter activity includes easy step-by-step instructions and a free printable template, making it perfect for classrooms, home projects, or Arctic animal lessons. Save this engaging craft idea for your next cold-weather activity with kids.
Santa Nutter Butters: A Jolly No-Bake Christmas Treat
Make these easy Santa Nutter Butters for a fun holiday treat kids will love. This simple no-bake recipe turns classic cookies into festive Santa snacks, perfect for school parties, family baking, or Christmas dessert trays. Pin and save the step-by-step guide for your next holiday activity.
Grinch Movie Night Ideas: Christmas Crafts, Snacks, and Fun for the Whole Family
Hosting a Grinch movie night for kids? This blog post has everything you need—creative crafts, hands-on activities, and delicious Grinch snacks for a festive family evening.
18 Grinch Crafts and Activities for Kids
Discover the best Grinch crafts and activities for kids—easy, festive, and perfect for holiday fun! From simple DIY crafts to playful learning activities, this Christmas roundup is great for preschool, toddlers, and early elementary.
Grinch Sensory Bin: A Playful and Heart-Growing Holiday Activity
Create holiday magic with this Grinch sensory bin for kids! This easy Christmas activity encourages hands-on learning, fine motor skills, and festive fun. Perfect for preschool, toddlers, and early learners.
Grinch Popsicle Stick Craft: A Whoville-Worthy Holiday Activity for Kids
Make Christmas extra fun with this adorable Grinch popsicle stick craft for kids! Easy, festive, and perfect for classroom parties, holiday playdates, or a cozy craft day at home.
Grinch Shake Recipe: A Whoville-Inspired Christmas Drink Recipe
A Grinch shake is a creamy Whoville-inspired Christmas drink recipe made with bright green ingredients and sweet toppings. Perfect for a holiday movie night.