Back-to-School Fun: Make This Adorable Pencil Cheese Ball for Your Next Gathering!

Looking for the perfect appetizer to kick off the school year, celebrate a teacher, or jazz up your child’s lunchbox party? Say hello to the Pencil Cheese Ball — a creamy, savory, crowd-pleasing snack that’s as cute as it is delicious!

This post contains Amazon Affiliate Links, I earn a small commission when you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you!

Whether you’re hosting a back-to-school brunch, planning a classroom celebration, or just want something fun for the kids after their first day, this pencil-shaped cheese ball is the ultimate edible centerpiece. It’s easy to make, packs a punch of flavor, and is guaranteed to spark some smiles!

Pencil Cheese Ball Recipe

Servings: 10–12
Prep Time: 30 minutes
Chill Time: 1 hour
Total Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Ingredients You’ll Need To Make the Pencil Cheese Ball:

2 (8 oz) blocks cream cheese, softened
3 cups finely shredded cheddar cheese (divided: 2 cups + 1 cup for coating)
2.5 tablespoons sour cream
1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
1/4 cup real bacon bits or pieces (optional)
1 oz packet ranch seasoning
4 oz diced pimientos, drained (for the “eraser”)
4 oz chopped black olives, drained (for the “pencil tip”)

Equipment:

Large mixing bowl
Plastic wrap
Serving platter

Directions:

1. Mix the Base
In a large mixing bowl, combine the softened cream cheese, 2 cups of shredded cheddar, sour cream, garlic powder, bacon bits (if using), and ranch seasoning. Stir until well combined.

2. Shape Your Pencil
Lay out a piece of plastic wrap, large enough to wrap your cheese mixture. Spoon the cheese mixture onto the center and fold the plastic over it. Gently shape the cheese ball into a long pencil form — one end tapered like a sharpened tip and the other flat like an eraser.

3. Chill It
Place the wrapped cheese pencil in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour. This helps it firm up and hold its shape.

4. Decorate the Pencil
Carefully unwrap the chilled cheese ball and transfer it to a serving platter. Press the remaining 1 cup of shredded cheddar around the middle to form the “wooden shaft” of the pencil.

5, Add the Eraser and Tip
At the flat end, press the diced pimientos to create a bright red “eraser.” At the pointed end, press in the chopped black olives to mimic the pencil’s lead tip.

6, Serve and Snack
Pair with crackers, wheat thins, or crunchy veggies. Watch it disappear!

Tips & Tricks:

Finer is better: Use finely shredded cheese and chopped olives to help everything stick and look polished.
Make it your own: Want extra flavor? Add finely chopped green onions or sub in your favorite savory mix-ins.
No bacon? No problem: Leave it out or replace with chopped sun-dried tomatoes or herbs for a vegetarian version.

Why The Pencil Cheese Ball is a Hit:

This Pencil Cheese Ball isn’t just cute — it’s also totally crave-worthy. The combo of cream cheese, cheddar, ranch, and bacon hits all the right salty-savory notes, and the design is perfect for themed events.

Use it for:

Teacher appreciation lunches
School-themed birthday parties
PTA meetings
First day of school treats
Kids’ charcuterie boards!

Make It a Full Back-to-School Bash!

Pair your Pencil Cheese Ball with some playful back-to-school books and activities to turn snack time into a full-on celebration!

Whether you’re easing first-day jitters or hosting a welcome-back party, these fun additions create connection, calm nerves, and build excitement for the year ahead.

Easy Activities for All Ages:

Make Your Own Name Tags
Set out markers, stickers, and pre-cut name tags. Kids can design their own — just like they would for the first day of school!
School Supplies Scavenger Hunt
Hide mini school items around the house or party area and let kids search for glue sticks, crayons, and erasers.
Classroom Role Play
Turn a corner of the room into a “pretend school” with a mini chalkboard, storybooks, and a stuffed animal classroom. Great for younger kids to explore school routines through play.
Back-to-School Photo Booth
Set up a simple backdrop and let kids pose with props like apple cutouts, mini backpacks, or chalkboard signs that say “Kindergarten Rocks!” or “Future Teacher!”

Must-Read Back-to-School Books:

The Kissing Hand by Audrey Penn
A tender, comforting read for any child feeling a little nervous about separating from home.
First Day Jitters by Julie Danneberg
This humorous twist reveals that even teachers get nervous about the first day!
School’s First Day of School by Adam Rex
Told from the school building’s point of view, this story is both clever and reassuring.
If You Take a Mouse to School by Laura Numeroff
Whimsical and fun, this one’s perfect for getting kids excited about classrooms and routines.
Our Class is a Family by Shannon Olsen
A wonderful reminder that school is more than a building — it’s a community where kids belong.