Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe·Leave a Review

a banana pudding mini pie with nilla wafers, edible grass, jelly beans, and a peeps bunny

With bunnies and candy as far as the eye can see, Easter is definitely dessert season. There are so many cute options out there, but few combine multiple holiday favorites into one like this Easter treat for kids. Peeps banana pudding mini pies are an adorable little Easter setup, complete with an Easter bunny and edible nest of eggs.

This post contains affiliate links. I earn a small commission if you choose to purchase, at no extra cost to you!

This simple Easter recipe combines store-bought mini pie crusts, banana cream pudding, and classic Easter candy. The result is an easy Easter dessert for kids that works well for classroom parties, family gatherings, homeschool celebrations, or a fun afternoon kitchen activity.

Little ones can also help decorate each pie, turning dessert preparation into a creative family activity.

Make Easter memorable with this letter from the Easter Bunny! Pop it in your child’s Easter basket or put it in an envelope and “mail” it.

a printable letter from the easter bunny

Why These Mini Pies Make a Perfect Easter Treat for Kids

The best Easter desserts for kids offer bright colors, soft textures, and easy assembly. Peeps banana pudding mini pies check every box.

Mini pie crusts provide a tasty base while creamy banana pudding fills the center with sweet flavor. Edible grass adds a nest-like layer, and jelly beans that resemble tiny Easter eggs bring bursts of color. A marshmallow Peeps bunny stands proudly on top, completing this cheerful edible scene.

Another advantage involves simplicity. This Easter recipe requires minimal preparation and no baking. Instant pudding does the heavy lifting while candy decorations create the fun.

Since each pie is its own individual serving, cleanup and portioning are easy. There’s no need for plates, and little hands can enjoy dessert without slicing or serving utensils.

Supplies Needed for This Easy Easter Recipe

supplies to make the Peeps Banana Pudding Mini Pies

Gather the following ingredients and supplies before assembling the Peeps banana pudding mini pies.

Ingredients

Mini graham cracker pie crusts
Banana cream instant pudding mix
Ingredients according to pudding package directions (typically milk)
Peeps bunny marshmallows
Edible Easter grass (shredded candy grass)
Jelly beans
Vanilla wafer cookies

Kitchen Supplies

Mixing bowl
Whisk
Spoon for filling pie crusts

These ingredients combine into a colorful Easter dessert for kids that looks like a tiny candy garden.

How to Make Peeps Banana Pudding Mini Pies

This Easter recipe comes together quickly and requires only a few simple steps.

1. Prepare the Banana Cream Pudding

Begin by preparing the banana cream instant pudding according to the instructions printed on the package. Typically this step involves whisking pudding mix with cold milk in a mixing bowl.

Continue whisking until the mixture thickens into smooth banana pudding. Allow the pudding to set for a few minutes so the texture thickens up a bit.

a mini pie crust with banana pudding inside

2. Fill the Mini Pie Crusts

Place the mini pie crusts on a tray or baking sheet. Spoon banana pudding into each crust until the filling reaches near the top edge.

A smooth layer creates the perfect base for candy decorations.

a mini banana pudding pie with edible easter grass on top

3. Add Edible Grass

Sprinkle edible Easter grass across the pudding. The thin strands create a nestlike effect while adding bright color to the yellow pudding.

a mini banana pudding pie with edible easter grass on top and nilla wafers

4. Place the Cookies

Insert two small cookies toward the back edge of each mini pie. The cookies add a soft crunch to the dessert. Vanilla wafers work especially well.

a mini banana pudding pie with edible easter grass, nilla wafers, and a blue peeps bunny

5. Add the Peeps Bunny

Place one Peeps bunny toward the back, next to the cookies. The marshmallow bunny stands in the edible grass, adding some marshmallowy goodness.

6. Decorate with Jelly Beans

Scatter jelly beans around the bunny to resemble colorful Easter eggs. Multicolored jelly beans populate a bright candy nest that contrasts beautifully with the soft banana pudding.

Serve immediately after decorating, or refrigerate the mini pies for about fifteen minutes to help the pudding firm up before serving.

Ways Kids Can Help Make This Easter Dessert

Cooking activities provide valuable hands-on learning for children. This Easter treat for kids offers several simple tasks that encourage creativity and participation.

Measuring and Mixing

Children can assist with pouring milk into the mixing bowl and whisking the pudding mixture. Stirring helps develop motor skills and introduces basic cooking steps.

Filling the Pie Crusts

A spoonful of pudding added to each mini crust allows kids to practice careful scooping and portioning. This step also builds confidence during kitchen activities.

Decorating the Candy Nests

Decorating is easily the most exciting part of this Easter recipe. Children can sprinkle edible grass, place cookies into the pudding, and arrange jelly beans in bright patterns.

Each mini pie is like a tiny edible art project.

Placing the Peeps Bunny

Adding the marshmallow bunny acts as the finishing touch. Careful placement teaches discretion and regulation of motor skills.

Participation in kid friendly recipes like this Easter dessert for kids encourages creativity while introducing basic food preparation skills.

Creative Variations for This Easter Recipe

Several easy variations can change the flavor or appearance of Peeps banana pudding mini pies.

Chocolate Banana Version
Add a layer of chocolate pudding beneath the banana pudding for a rich chocolate-banana flavor combination.

Strawberry Spring Pies
Replace banana pudding with strawberry pudding and decorate with pink jelly beans and yellow Peeps chicks.

Whipped Cream Garden
Top the pudding layer with a small swirl of whipped topping before adding candy decorations.

Candy Egg Nest
Swap jelly beans for mini chocolate eggs to create a slightly richer Easter dessert.

Each variation maintains the playful candy nest appearance while introducing new flavors.

Serving and Storage Tips For This Peeps Dessert

Serve Peeps banana pudding mini pies chilled for the best texture. Cold pudding helps the mini pies hold their shape while keeping the candy decorations in place.

For gatherings or parties, arrange the mini pies on a large platter to create a colorful dessert display. The bright Peeps dessert immediately catches attention and brings cheerful spring energy to the table.

If preparation happens ahead of time, cover the mini pies with plastic wrap and refrigerate until serving. Decorations and pudding will keep for several hours.

A Sweet and Simple Easter Dessert for Kids

Peeps banana pudding mini pies combine classic Easter candy with creamy banana pudding and crunchy cookies to create an easy Easter treat for kids. No baking, simple ingredients, and colorful decorations make kid friendly Easter recipes like this one perfect for classrooms, family celebrations, or homeschool holiday activities.

Small hands can help assemble each pie, so dessert preparation is a creative experience filled with color and imagination. The final result looks like a tiny candy garden with a marshmallow bunny standing proudly among bright jelly bean eggs.

Each bite brings creamy banana pudding, crunchy cookie texture, and sweet candy flavor together in a cheerful Easter dessert that children are sure to love.

Easter Books To Read

Happy Easter, Biscuit!: A Lift-the-Flap Book: An Easter And Springtime Book For Kids

~~$6.99~~ $5.59